How to Increase Profits: 7 Proven Ways for Marketing Agencies

Marketing agencies often find themselves working harder but making less. More clients, more projects, but profits don’t seem to grow. That’s because typical business advice doesn’t match the reality of agency life: tight deadlines, creative demands, and unpredictable scopes.

These 7 profitability strategies are specifically designed for marketing agencies seeking how to increase profits within 90 days. Each addresses real agency challenges, from hourly billing traps to operational inefficiencies, with practical solutions that generate more profit without sacrificing quality.

1. Switch from Hourly to Value-Based Pricing

Hourly billing caps your profit potential by tying revenue to time spent rather than value delivered. When you charge hourly, efficiency is penalized, the better you become, the less you earn.

Value-based pricing changes everything. Instead of selling time, you sell outcomes and results. A website redesign increasing conversion rates by 30% delivers measurable value far beyond hours invested.

Simple Transition Framework

Quantify Client Outcomes: Calculate financial impact of your work. If SEO increased organic traffic 200%, translate that into dollar value using their conversion rates and customer lifetime value.

Package Your Services: Replace “20 hours of social media management” with outcome-focused packages like “Brand Authority Builder” or “Lead Generation System.”

Transition Gradually: Introduce value-based pricing for new projects or renewals. Explain benefits: predictable costs, results focus, and your increased incentive for quick delivery.

2. Optimize Your Services

Not all marketing services generate equal profits. Many agencies offer low-margin services that consume resources while contributing minimally to the bottom line.

Conduct a profitability audit of every service. Calculate true delivery costs including team time, tools, overhead, and opportunity cost. You’ll discover some “profitable” services actually operate at breakeven.

High-margin services typically:

• Require specialized expertise commanding premium pricing
• Generate recurring revenue through retainers
• Scale efficiently without proportional resource increases
• Deliver measurable, long-term client value

Examples of high-margin services:

• SEO retainers with performance guarantees
• Marketing automation setup and optimization
• Strategic consulting and planning
• Content strategy development
• Performance marketing with revenue-sharing

Low-margin services often involve:

• High time investment with minimal scalability
• Commoditized offerings easily compared on price
• Extensive revisions and scope creep
• Limited ongoing value after initial delivery

Strategic Restructuring Approach

Eliminate or Restructure: Phase out services with margins below 30%. If clients depend on these services, bundle them with high-margin offerings or increase pricing significantly.

Bundle for Value: Create service packages combining complementary offerings. Instead of separate maintenance, content, and social media services, offer “Digital Presence Accelerator” packages at premium pricing.

Focus on Recurring Revenue: Prioritize retainer relationships over one-time projects. Monthly SEO, ongoing content creation, and performance monitoring provide predictable revenue and deeper client relationships.

3. Use Automation Tools

Operational inefficiencies silently drain agency profits through wasted time, repeated manual tasks, and poor resource utilization. The question of how to increase profitability often comes down to doing more with existing resources rather than adding costs.

Here are 4 things you can do. 

Automate Client Onboarding: Create standardized workflows for new client setup. Automated welcome sequences, document collection, and project kickoff processes reduce administrative time by 60-70% while improving client experience.

Streamline Reporting: Manual report creation consumes 8-12 hours monthly per client. Automated dashboards and scheduled reports free account managers for strategic work while providing clients with real-time access to performance data.

Optimize Creative Workflows: Implement approval systems that prevent endless revision cycles. Clear feedback protocols, structured review processes, and automated notifications keep projects moving efficiently.

Track Utilization Rates: Monitor how team members spend time across billable and non-billable activities. Target 75-80% billable utilization for account managers and 70-75% for creative staff, accounting for necessary administrative tasks.

Essential automation tools for agencies:

• Project management systems with automated task assignment
• Time tracking integrated with billing systems
• Client communication platforms with templated responses
• Social media scheduling and content distribution
• Proposal generation with standardized pricing

Implementation priority: Start with your most time-consuming, repetitive tasks. Client onboarding and reporting typically offer the biggest immediate returns on automation investment.

The goal isn’t eliminating human touch but removing manual busy work that prevents team members from focusing on high-value, profit-generating activities. Smart automation increases both profitability and job satisfaction by letting creative professionals do what they do best.

4. Outsource Web Development and Design 

Hiring in-house developers and designers sounds logical until you face the reality. For example, imagine you are working with WordPress. A WordPress developer needs salary, benefits, equipment, training, and management time. Add a designer to the mix, and you’re looking at substantial overhead before they complete a single project.

The real problem here is unpredictable workload. Some months you have five website projects, others you have none. Your in-house team sits idle during slow periods while you’re still paying full salaries, or you’re scrambling to find freelancers when multiple projects hit at once.

Outsourcing web development and design solves the scalability problem completely. You can ramp up for big projects and scale down during quiet periods without the overhead burden of full-time staff.

Why This Approach Works Particularly Well for WordPress Projects

WordPress development has clear specifications and deliverables, making it perfect for remote teams. Whether you’re building custom themes, e-commerce sites, or membership platforms, the scope is defined upfront with measurable milestones.

The flexibility advantage is huge. Need three developers for a month-long project? Done. Only need design work for one project? No problem. You can pay for exactly what you need when you need it, instead of maintaining expensive bench capacity.

How to Make It Work

The key is treating outsourced teams as an extension of your agency, not just vendors for individual projects. When done right, outsourcing gives you enterprise-level capabilities with startup-level flexibility.

1. Partner with teams that specialize in agency workflows. Look for development and design partners who understand your timelines, communication style, and quality standards without extensive hand-holding.
2. Create standardized handoff processes. Develop project briefs, milestone schedules, and review checkpoints that work consistently across different projects and team sizes.
3. Start with smaller projects to test capabilities. Don’t immediately outsource your biggest client’s website redesign. Begin with simpler WordPress customizations or landing pages to evaluate quality and communication flow.
4. Ask for NDAs. Always look for partners that offer non-disclosure agreements and act as invisible partners. 

5. Review the Client Portfolio 

Not all clients are created equal, but most agencies treat them like they are. The client paying $2,000 monthly who demands constant revisions and calls emergency meetings over minor changes is actually costing you money. Meanwhile, the client paying $5,000 monthly who trusts your expertise and provides clear feedback is pure profit.

Do a client profitability analysis that goes beyond just revenue. Track the real cost of serving each client:

• How much time does their account team spend on calls and emails?
• How many revisions do their projects typically require?
• How often do they request rush jobs or scope changes?
• What’s their payment history like?

You’ll probably discover some uncomfortable truths:

• Your biggest clients aren’t always your most profitable
• Some clients consume resources way out of proportion to what they pay
• The clients who negotiated the hardest on price are usually the most demanding to serve

What You Can Do with This Information

Transition problem clients gradually. Don’t fire everyone at once, but start having honest conversations about scope, expectations, and pricing. Some clients will adjust their behavior when they understand the real cost of their demands.

Focus your marketing on attracting better clients. If you’re most profitable working with tech companies that understand digital marketing, stop trying to win restaurant accounts just because they’re available.

Raise prices strategically. Use renewal periods to bring pricing in line with the actual cost of service. Some clients will leave, but you’ll be more profitable with fewer, better-paying clients.

Create systems that prevent scope creep. Clear contracts, defined revision limits, and change order processes protect your margins from clients who want to expand projects without expanding budgets.

6. Audit Your Spending

Most agencies spend money on subscriptions, tools, and processes they don’t actually need. The average agency pays for 15-20 different software tools, many of which overlap in functionality or get used by only one person occasionally.

Audit your entire tech stack ruthlessly. List every subscription, what it costs annually, who uses it, and whether it’s actually essential. You’ll probably find:

• Multiple tools that do similar things
• Expensive enterprise plans when basic plans would work fine
• Software that only one person uses occasionally
• Tools that were needed for one project but never cancelled

Consolidate where possible. Instead of separate tools for project management, time tracking, and client communication, find platforms that handle multiple functions well. You’ll save money and reduce the training burden on your team.

Negotiate everything. Annual contracts almost always offer discounts over monthly billing. If you’re a good customer, ask for better rates. Many SaaS companies will negotiate, especially if you’re considering alternatives.

Right-size your team structure. Do you really need a full-time social media manager if you only have three clients who need social media? Consider freelancers or part-time specialists for roles that don’t require 40 hours weekly.

But don’t cut costs that directly impact quality or efficiency. Saving $200 monthly on a design tool that slows down your creative team by 20% is a false economy. Focus on eliminating waste, not crippling operations.

Track the real ROI of your expenses. That $500/month marketing automation tool might seem expensive until you realize it saves 15 hours of manual work weekly. At $100/hour, that’s a $6,000 monthly value for a $500 investment.

7. Track Agency-Specific Profit Metrics

Most agencies track vanity metrics like total revenue or number of clients, but these don’t tell you if you’re actually making money. You need to focus on metrics that directly impact your bottom line.

Essential Profitability Metrics for Agencies

1. Gross margin per client: Calculate total revenue minus direct costs (team time, tools, outsourcing) for each client. This shows which relationships are actually profitable versus just generating revenue.
2. Utilization rates: Track how much time your team spends on billable work versus administrative tasks. Account managers should hit 75-80% billable time, creatives around 70-75%. Lower rates signal operational inefficiencies eating your profits.
3. Client lifetime value: Don’t just look at monthly retainer amounts. Factor in project add-ons, contract length, and referral value. Some clients who seem small monthly actually generate more long-term profit than bigger accounts.
4. Average project profitability: Track which types of projects consistently make money and which ones drain resources. This data drives smart decisions about what services to promote and what to phase out.
5. Set up monthly profit reviews: Spend an hour each month reviewing these metrics with your leadership team. Look for trends, identify problem areas early, and adjust strategies before small issues become big profit drains.
6. Create early warning systems: If client utilization drops below target levels or project margins start shrinking, you need to know immediately, not at the end of the quarter when it’s too late to fix.

The goal isn’t to become obsessed with numbers, but to have clear visibility into what’s driving profitability so you can make informed decisions about pricing, services, and client relationships.

Final Words: How to Increase Profitability

These seven strategies aren’t theoretical concepts, they’re practical changes that work in the real world of client deadlines, scope creep, and competitive pressures. The agencies seeing the biggest profit improvements are those that stop treating profitability as an afterthought and start building it into every business decision.

If you ever need an outsourcing partner for WordPress development and design, WLA specializes in helping marketing agencies scale without the overhead costs. We understand agency workflows and can become an extension of your team. Get in touch with us to learn more about our services.

FAQs